The Effect of Taiwan’s Same-Sex Marriage Ruling on Surrogacy

On May 24, 2017, Taiwan became the first Asian country to legalize same-sex marriage. In doing so, it not only opened the doors for same-sex couples wanting to marry, but also provided them with the opportunity to have children by a surrogate.

One of the issues that previously prevented same-sex couples, more specifically, those in Asia from making use of international surrogacy services, was the issue of parentage. Because same-sex marriage was not legally recognized in Asia, “parentage” was only characterized as being between a woman and man. For this reason, couples would list the surrogate mother or sperm donor as the second parent. Though this potential quick fix served as a temporary resolution to a problem, this “loophole” raised an equally troubling question of whether the sperm or egg donor (“second listed parent”) should be entitled to parental rights or responsibilities. Furthermore, it also created an issue of child custody in the event the same-sex couple were to divorce, because only one of the “intended parents” was listed as the child’s parent.

Following Taiwan’s recent change in legalization, same-sex couples seeking international surrogacy in Asia will no longer have to sidestep parentage. Now that their marriage will be recognized in Taiwan, intended parents, irrespective of their sex, can now legally list themselves as their child’s parents. Taiwan’s court ruling is not only a step forward in acceptance of the right to marry, but a step forward in acceptance of the ability of same-sex parents to raise a child.

To learn more about international surrogacy law, or to seek counsel for international surrogacy or other family law matters, please do not hesitate to contact Evie P. Jeang, Managing Partner of Ideal Legal Group and Founder of Surrogacy Concierges.

 

台湾同性婚姻合法化对代孕产生的影响

在2017年5月24号,台湾成为亚洲第一个以法律保障同性婚姻的地区。台湾承认同性婚姻合法,不仅让同性人士的婚姻得到法律保障,更让他们有机会通过委托代理孕母怀孕生子,完成生儿育女的愿望。

代孕生育子女亲权认定问题是阻止同性伴侣,尤其是生活在亚洲的伴侣,使用跨国代孕服务的主要原因之一。因为同性婚姻在亚洲不受法律认可,亲子关系认定成为了异性伴侣独有的特权。由于这个原因,同性伴侣不得不将代孕母或者精子/卵子捐献者列为父母一方。虽然说此举能暂时解决某些代孕问题,但同时也存在引发亲子关系纠纷的隐患,比如说精子/卵子捐献者是否有权得到孩子的监护权。再者,当同性伴侣打算离婚时,孩子的监护权可能成为最繁琐的纠纷之一,因为在同性伴侣中只有一方是被法律认定的亲生父母。

跟随着台湾法律的改变,需要使用跨国代孕的亚洲同性伴侣不需要再放弃孩子的亲子权利。现在他们的/她们的婚姻被台湾法律认可,想成为准父母的他们/她们可无需考虑自己的性别,双双拥有孩子的亲权认定权利。台湾法庭的决定不仅在婚姻平权上跨出重要一步,也在同性伴侣就生儿育女方面作出极大贡献。

想要更详细地了解跨国代孕法,跨国代孕服务或其他家庭法事物的服务,欢迎与理想法律团队董事及爱儿代孕服务中心创始人蒋佩芳律师(Evie P. Jeang)联系。